Funeral Home Litigation
Who may bring a claim against a funeral home, crematory, or cemetery?
When something goes wrong with a loved one's body or ashes, the whole family feels it. The law, though, sorts people into different roles, and a claim usually belongs to some of them and not others. This page explains the roles in plain language. It is general information, not legal advice. Who holds which claim in your family is something we work out with you on the first call.
Four roles that come up
1. The person Florida law puts first in line to decide
Chapter 497 defines a "legally authorized person," in this priority: the decedent's own written directions; the person named on a military DD Form 93 if the decedent died in service; the surviving spouse; a son or daughter who is 18 or older; a parent; a brother or sister who is 18 or older; a grandchild who is 18 or older; a grandparent; and then any person in the next degree of kinship (§ 497.005(43)(a)). If no family member exists or is available, the list can reach others, such as a guardian, the personal representative, or a health surrogate (§ 497.005(43)(b)). The same definition says that a person who has been arrested for committing an act of domestic violence against the deceased, or any act that resulted in or contributed to the death, is not accorded any legally recognizable interest under it.
This list tells a funeral home whose permission it needs. It does not say, in so many words, who may sue. Chapter 497 lists, among the grounds for discipline of a licensee, taking possession of a dead human body without first getting permission from a legally authorized person, and failing to get written authorization from a legally authorized person before burial, interment, or disinterment (§ 497.152(8)(c), (e)). For a cremation, the chapter says it may not be performed until a legally authorized person gives written authorization (§ 497.607(1)). A problem with permission can be where a claim starts, depending on the facts.
2. The person who signed the contract
The family member who signed the funeral or cremation contract may have rights under that contract, depending on its terms and the facts. Sometimes that is the same person as the first role. Sometimes it is not. Another relative may have signed because they were the one who could get to the funeral home that day.
3. "Any person" under Chapter 497
Florida lets the Attorney General, the Department of Financial Services on behalf of Florida residents, or "any person" bring a civil action against a person or company violating Chapter 497. On adverse adjudication, the defendant is liable for the actual damages caused by the violation, and the court may award punitive damages as provided by common law and may provide such equitable relief as it deems proper or necessary (§ 497.169(1)). This chapter is also cumulative to rights under the general civil and common law, and no action of the department can take those rights away (§ 497.169(3)).
"Any person" is broad language. It does not mean every relative can recover for every harm. Which relative can recover, and for what, is a legal question we answer from your facts.
4. The personal representative of the estate
In a wrongful death case, Florida law says the action is brought by the decedent's personal representative, who recovers for the benefit of the decedent's survivors and the estate (§ 768.20). "Survivors" is a defined term: the decedent's spouse, children, parents, and, when partly or wholly dependent on the decedent for support or services, any blood relatives and adoptive brothers and sisters (§ 768.18(1)). The complaint must identify all potential beneficiaries and their relationships to the decedent (§ 768.21).
Wrongful death is one claim. Mishandled remains are another.
Florida's wrongful death statute applies when a person's death is caused by the wrongful act, negligence, default, or breach of contract or warranty of another, and the event would have entitled the person who was injured to bring an action and recover damages had death not ensued (§ 768.19).
Many funeral home problems happen after the death. Ashes mixed up, a body not refrigerated, remains sent to the wrong person: the harm is to the family and to how their loved one was treated. That is a different question from what caused the death. A lawyer can tell you whether your situation involves one claim, the other, or both. A family may have both, for example when the death itself involved a medical or accident claim and the funeral home later mishandled the body.
If the family does not agree
Families disagree, especially about cremation versus burial and about who gets the ashes. Chapter 497 says that where there is a person in a priority class, the funeral establishment relies on the authorization of any one legally authorized person of that class if that person represents that she or he is not aware of any objection to the cremation by others in the same class or by anyone in a higher class (§ 497.005(43)(b)). The chapter also says that dividing cremated remains requires the consent of the legally authorized person who approved the cremation, and that a dispute about dividing cremated remains is resolved by a court of competent jurisdiction (§ 497.607(2)). Who holds the right to decide, and who may bring a claim, can turn on details. Talk to a lawyer before anyone signs a release or settlement for the family.
What to do now
- Write down who signed what, and when.
- Keep every document: the contract, price list, receipts, authorization forms, and the death certificate.
- Make a simple family tree: spouse, children, parents, brothers and sisters.
- Do not sign anything from the funeral home without asking a lawyer.
More steps: What to do right now.
Questions families ask
Does the person who signed the contract have the only claim?
Not necessarily. The signer may have rights under the contract. Chapter 497 also lets "any person" bring a civil action against a licensee that violates the chapter (§ 497.169(1)). Who has a claim depends on the facts and the kind of claim, so we sort it out at the start.
Can a brother, sister, or grandchild bring a claim?
Possibly. A brother or sister who is 18 or older and a grandchild who is 18 or older both appear in Florida's priority list (§ 497.005(43)(a)). That list is about who directs the arrangements, not about who can recover. Whether they can recover depends on the claim and on who else is in the family. Call and we will walk through it.
What if the family disagrees?
It happens often, and it is nobody's fault. Talk to a lawyer before anyone signs a release or accepts an offer, so the family understands what it would be giving up.
Is this a wrongful death case?
Maybe, maybe not. Wrongful death is about what caused the death. How remains were handled after death is a separate question, and a lawyer can sort out which applies.
Talk to Dennis
When you are ready, call or send a WhatsApp message, in English or Spanish. We will listen first.
You can read about some of our past cases on our Results page.
Former Miami-Dade prosecutor · Since 2012 · Super Lawyers Rising Stars · Avvo Rating 10.0
Funeral negligence · By area
Funeral negligence lawyer by city and county
- Funeral Home LitigationAll funeral home, crematory and cemetery topics.
- License lookup and complaint guideCheck a Florida funeral home, crematory or cemetery license and send the state a complaint.
- MiamiWhere a Miami case is filed, and who to call first.
- HialeahThe paperwork, the Hialeah courthouse and the state's list.
- Miami BeachFor residents, and for families of visitors.
- KendallCremation rules and the courts that serve Kendall.
- HomesteadGraves, plots and the South Dade Justice Center.
- Miami GardensPrepaid plans, closed funeral homes and the state hotline.
- Coral GablesLost graves, dignity and the Coral Gables Branch Court.
- DoralWhen a loved one is sent to another country.
- Broward CountyBroward courthouses, medical examiner and city cemeteries.
- Palm Beach CountyCounty courthouses, the District 15 medical examiner, local cemeteries.