Premises Liability
Attacked where there should have been security? What negligent security means in Miami.
Negligent security means a property owner or operator failed to take reasonable steps to protect people from foreseeable crime, and someone was hurt as a result. The attacker is responsible for the attack. The property may also be responsible if the danger was foreseeable and the security was inadequate. We can tell you for free whether your facts fit.
What is a negligent security claim?
It is a claim against a property owner or operator, not just the person who committed the crime. The idea is that some places owe visitors and residents reasonable protection from crime that could be anticipated, and that missing locks, lights, cameras or guards can be a failure of that duty.
This is not an insurance claim against the criminal. Many attackers are never found. A negligent security claim looks at the property.
Where do negligent security cases happen?
Common settings include apartment and condo complexes, hotels, bars and nightclubs, parking lots and garages, shopping centers, convenience stores, gas stations and event venues.
Examples of problems we look for: broken gates or door locks, burned-out lights, no working cameras, no patrol, a history of prior incidents with no changes, and bars that let a known threat stay inside.
What do I have to prove?
The simple answer: the owner or operator owed you a duty, the crime was foreseeable, security was not reasonable, and that failure helped cause your injury.
Foreseeability is often the heart of the case. Records of earlier crimes at or near the property, police calls, resident complaints and the owner's own emails can show what the owner knew.
Did the law change in 2023?
Yes, in ways that matter. A 2023 Florida law requires the jury in these cases to consider the fault of everyone who contributed to the injury, including the attacker. It also gives owners of apartment, townhouse and condo properties with at least five units a legal presumption against liability for crimes by outsiders if they substantially put in place a list of security measures, such as entry cameras, parking-lot and walkway lighting, deadbolts, window locks, a security assessment and staff training.
Because the details are technical, and because the text can be amended, we check the current version for every case. Do not rely on a general summary like this one for your own deadline or rights.
How is fault divided when a criminal caused the harm?
Florida requires the jury to consider the fault of the person who committed the crime when dividing responsibility, and this can reduce what a property pays. A victim found more than 50 percent at fault generally cannot recover.
That does not mean a property is off the hook. It means the evidence about security failures needs to be strong and specific. Insurers fight these cases hard.
What should I do after an attack on a property?
- Call 911 and get medical care. Keep the report numbers.
- Tell the manager, landlord or bar and ask for a written incident report.
- Photograph the scene: doors, gates, lights, cameras and signs.
- Write down what staff said and did, and who was on duty.
- Get names of witnesses and other residents who had problems before.
- Save lease papers, texts, emails and complaint letters to the landlord.
- Do not post about it or give a recorded statement to an insurer.
- Call us so we can send a preservation letter for video, logs and prior-incident records.
How long do I have to file?
For most negligence claims arising after March 24, 2023, the general deadline is two years. Surveillance video and guard logs are often kept for a short time, so do not wait.
If a criminal case is pending against the attacker, the civil deadline still runs. Speaking with us does not interfere with the criminal case. Our firm also practices criminal defense, so we understand both sides of the courthouse.
What can a claim recover?
A claim may seek compensation for medical bills, lost income, pain, and other harms the law allows. We do not promise a result or a number. Each case turns on its facts and the available insurance.
For the broader topic, read Premises liability in Miami, Unsafe property and catastrophic injury, Injured at an event or festival and Personal injury in Miami.
Questions people ask
What is negligent security?
It is a property owner or operator failing to provide reasonable protection from foreseeable crime.
Can I sue the apartment complex if I was assaulted there?
Possibly. It depends on whether the attack was foreseeable and whether security was reasonable. We review prior incidents and conditions.
Can a bar or nightclub be responsible for a fight or shooting?
In some cases. Florida law sharply limits when a bar can be held responsible for serving alcohol to adults, but separate security duties may apply.
What if the attacker is never caught?
You may still have a claim against the property. The claim looks at what the property did or failed to do.
How long do I have?
For most negligence claims arising after March 24, 2023, two years.
Will a prior crime at the property matter?
Often yes. Prior incidents can show that the owner knew or should have known of the danger. The details decide the weight.
Call or WhatsApp
Free, confidential, any hour: Call (305) 209-0384 WhatsApp