Two people can face the same number of counts and walk away with very different amounts of real prison time. The difference is often one word in the sentencing order: concurrent or consecutive.
This post explains what those words mean in Florida, who decides, and how victims and families are heard at sentencing. It is general information and does not discuss any specific case.
Concurrent vs consecutive, in plain language
- Concurrent means the sentences run at the same time.
- Consecutive means they stack, one after the other.
Here is a simple example with made-up numbers. Say a person is sentenced to 5 years on each of three counts. If the sentences are concurrent, the total time is 5 years. If they are consecutive, the total time can be 15 years.
Same counts. Same judge. Ten years apart.
What the Florida statute says
Section 921.16(1), Florida Statutes, sets the default rules. For counts in the same charging document, a defendant:
"shall serve the sentences of imprisonment concurrently unless the court directs that two or more of the sentences be served consecutively"
So when the counts are charged together, the default is concurrent, and the judge has to direct otherwise to stack them.
The rule flips for separate cases. The same section says:
"Sentences of imprisonment for offenses not charged in the same indictment, information, or affidavit shall be served consecutively unless the court directs"
So sentences from separate cases default to consecutive unless the judge directs otherwise. That is one reason the structure of a plea deal matters so much when a person has more than one case open.
The statute also contains specific requirements for certain offenses. For example, section 921.16(1) requires that sentences for murder or sexual battery from separate episodes run consecutively. Those are limits on the judge's choice, and they are why the answer to this question always starts with the exact charges.
Questions about your situation? Talk to Dennis.
The scoresheet
Florida sentences are calculated using a scoresheet. Section 921.0024 provides that:
"The Criminal Punishment Code worksheet is used to compute the subtotal and total sentence points"
The points on the scoresheet drive the sentencing range. Scoresheet errors happen, and one wrong entry can change the numbers, so a defense lawyer checks it line by line.
Victim and family statements at sentencing
Victims have a voice at sentencing. Section 921.143(1) refers to:
"the next of kin of the victim if the victim has died from causes related to the crime"
and to statements made:
"making a statement under oath for the record"
So in a case involving a death, next of kin may address the court, and those statements are made under oath.
The Florida Constitution also addresses this. Article I, section 16(b)(6)b. provides:
"The right to be heard in any public proceeding involving pretrial or other release from any form of legal constraint, plea, sentencing"
What do these statements change? Judges listen. A statement can help the court understand the harm. But the judge still has to follow the law, including the scoresheet, so a statement does not override what the statute requires.
What a defense lawyer does before sentencing
- Builds the mitigation package. Work history, family, treatment, community ties and the person behind the charge.
- Reviews the scoresheet. Checks every entry and the resulting range.
- Negotiates structure. In a plea, how the counts run (concurrent or consecutive) can matter as much as the number itself.
- Prepares the client. Knowing what to expect in the room, including victim statements, makes a hard day more manageable.
Frequently asked questions
What does it mean when sentences run concurrently?
They run at the same time, so the total time is generally the longest single sentence, not the sum.
Can a judge make sentences consecutive in Florida?
Yes. Under section 921.16(1), the court can direct that sentences be served consecutively, and in some situations the statute requires it.
Can the victim's family influence the sentence?
Victims and next of kin may be heard at sentencing, and in a death case statements are made under oath. The judge listens but must follow the law.
Does a plea deal fix concurrent time?
Not automatically. Under section 921.16(1), the court directs whether sentences run concurrently or consecutively, so ask how the agreement addresses it before you sign.
Facing multiple counts?
Ask how the sentences will be structured before you accept any offer.
Dennis Gonzalez Law, P.A. is led by a former Miami-Dade prosecutor who now defends people charged with crimes in state and federal court. Call (305) 209-0384, answered 24/7. The first consultation is free.
Learn more about criminal defense in Miami.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts.