In this article
After a death caused by a crime, families often hear that the case is going forward. What many do not realize is that there can be two cases, and they are not the same thing.
This guide explains how a criminal case and a wrongful death case differ in Florida, who can bring the civil claim, and when a business may be part of the picture. It does not discuss any specific case.
Two different cases, two different goals
The criminal case is brought by the State. Its purpose is to decide whether a person committed a crime and, if so, to punish that person. The family is not the party that brings it. The family may be a witness and may have the right to be heard at certain stages.
The wrongful death case is a civil claim. Its purpose is to hold someone responsible and to recover compensation for the losses the death caused. Florida law allows this claim even when the death was a crime. Section 768.19 says the person responsible is liable "although death was caused under circumstances constituting a felony."
One does not replace the other. A civil case can exist whether or not there is an arrest, a trial, or a conviction.
Who can file a wrongful death claim?
Not the whole family at once. Under section 768.20, "The action shall be brought by the decedent’s personal representative." That person then recovers for the benefit of the survivors and the estate.
- The personal representative is the person appointed to handle the estate.
- The survivors are defined in section 768.18: the spouse, children, parents, and, when partly or wholly dependent on the person for support or services, other blood relatives and adoptive brothers and sisters.
If no one has been appointed yet, that is one of the first steps to talk through with a lawyer.
Questions about your situation? Talk to Dennis.
What can the family recover?
Section 768.21 lists the damages. Depending on who the survivors are, they can include:
- Loss of the person's companionship and protection, and mental pain and suffering for a surviving spouse
- Lost support and services
- Certain losses for children and parents
- Medical and funeral expenses
- Losses to the estate
The exact categories depend on who survives and on the facts. A lawyer can tell you what applies to your family.
Does the criminal result affect the civil case?
It can. A criminal conviction can lock in the facts for the civil case. Section 775.089(8) says a conviction involving the act that gives rise to restitution "shall estop the defendant from denying the essential allegations of that offense in any subsequent civil proceeding."
When a business may be responsible
Sometimes a person is hurt or killed by another person on a business's property, such as a parking lot, an apartment complex, a store or a bar. In some situations the owner can be responsible for failing to keep people reasonably safe. This is often called negligent security.
Three points to keep in mind:
- The facts decide. These cases look at what the business knew, what it did, and what it should have done.
- The jury weighs everyone's fault. Under section 768.0701, in these cases the trier of fact must consider "the fault of all persons who contributed to the injury," including the person who committed the crime.
- Some apartment owners have a presumption in their favor. Section 768.0706 can give certain multifamily properties a presumption against liability when they meet listed security requirements. That section creates no right to sue on its own, and it does not apply to every property.
These cases are hard and fact-heavy. Do not assume you have one, and do not assume you do not.
Deadlines
Most wrongful death claims in Florida must be started within two years. Section 95.11(5)(e) lists "An action for wrongful death" among the actions that must be brought within two years.
There is an exception for claims against the person who killed, in cases of murder or manslaughter. Section 95.11(11) says that kind of claim against a natural person may be commenced at any time, and it does not require an arrest, formal charges, or a conviction. That exception does not extend the time for a claim against a business.
Waiting costs families evidence, witnesses and records. Call early, even if you are not sure what to do.
Frequently asked questions
Can a family sue after a criminal trial in Florida?
Yes. The civil wrongful death claim is separate from the criminal case. It is brought by the personal representative.
What is a personal representative?
The person appointed to handle the decedent's estate. Under the Wrongful Death Act, this person files the claim for the survivors and the estate.
What is negligent security?
A claim that a property owner or business failed to take reasonable steps to keep people safe from foreseeable harm. Each case depends on its facts.
Can the family sue if no one is ever arrested?
A civil claim does not depend on an arrest or conviction. A claim against the person who committed a murder or manslaughter can be brought at any time, and the statute says no arrest or conviction is required.
Talk to us, free
If you have lost someone and want to understand your family's options, call Dennis Gonzalez Law, P.A. at (305) 209-0384. We answer 24/7. The first consultation is free.
Learn more about personal injury and wrongful death.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts.