Your phone buzzes. Zelle says you got $800. You do not know who sent it.

Do you keep it? Do you send it back? Can you just say nothing and let it sit there?

People argue about this all the time. Some say it is free money. Some say it is theft. The honest answer sits in between. It depends on what you knew and what you did next.

Here is how the argument runs, and where the law is clear and where it is not.

Do I have to give it back?

Generally, yes, unless you have a real legal claim to the money.

The money was not meant for you. Florida courts say a person who receives money by mistake must return it, unless that person has a legal or fair claim to it. That holds even if you did nothing wrong. The legal ideas have names like unjust enrichment and money had and received. You do not need to be a thief for them to apply. The basic idea is fairness: a person should not hold on to money that, in good conscience, should go back.

There is a narrow exception. In an old Florida case, a man kept a mistaken payment that he took, in good faith, as payment of a real debt the payer owed him. He did not have to give it back. A friend who truly owes you money may fit. A stranger's payment usually will not.

A sender can generally sue to recover the money. For smaller amounts that may mean small claims court, which in Florida handles claims up to $8,000. Larger amounts go to county court or above.

Spending it does not get you out of this. A Florida appeals court has said that having spent the money is not enough to avoid paying it back.

Refusing can make it worse. If the sender demands the money and you refuse, that refusal can be a civil wrong called conversion. That can be true even if you honestly thought you could keep it.

Getting the money was not your fault. What you do next is what counts.

Can I stay quiet and spend it?

You should not. It is a bad idea.

Staying quiet while the money sits there is one thing. Spending it after you know it is not yours is another. That second step is where the real risk starts.

Keep this in mind: the law looks at what you knew. If a message says "sorry, wrong person," and you spend the money anyway, that message can become evidence of what you knew.

Silence has limits too. In one Florida civil case, a man got $10,000 through a bank error and was not asked for it until years later. The court said a jury could find he formed the intent to keep it only when a demand to return it went unanswered. So do not ignore a real demand letter. Take it to a lawyer.

Questions about your situation? Talk to Dennis.

Is it finders keepers? Why not?

Not as a simple rule in Florida. Not even for property that is truly lost.

Florida's law on lost property tells a finder to report it. It also says it is unlawful for anyone who finds lost or abandoned property "to appropriate the same to his or her own use or to refuse to deliver the same when required." Section 705.102(3), Florida Statutes. A person who does that commits theft. A finder can end up owning lost property through the police process in that chapter, after a 90-day period, if no owner claims it.

Here is the honest catch. That law is about tangible things that someone mislaid. A Zelle credit is not a lost wallet. The sender is usually known, and the money is not sitting on a park bench. So that statute does not govern a Zelle payment.

The lesson is still useful. If the law does not let you simply keep a lost item you found on the street, it is hard to see why it would let you keep money with a name attached. That last step is our reasoning, not a court ruling.

Could it be a crime?

Yes, it can.

Florida's theft statute covers a person who "knowingly obtains or uses" the property of another, with intent to deprive the owner of it, or to use it as their own. Section 812.014(1), Florida Statutes. The phrase "obtains or uses" is defined broadly. It includes "exercising control over property" and "any unauthorized use, disposition, or transfer of property." Section 812.012(3).

This is not just theory. A Florida appeals court upheld a grand theft conviction where a man hurriedly spent large sums he reasonably knew a bank had put in his account by error. The amount was more than $47,000. Long before that, the Florida Supreme Court upheld a larceny conviction where a man knowingly walked out of a bank with more than $4,000 on a $36 check. Neither case involved Zelle, but both involved money that arrived by mistake.

So how serious can it get? That depends on the amount. These are the basic maximum jail or prison terms, not predictions. Fines can apply too, and a prior record can raise the level:

  • Under $100: a second-degree misdemeanor, up to 60 days.
  • $100 to under $750: a first-degree misdemeanor, up to one year.
  • $750 to under $20,000: a third-degree felony, up to five years.
  • $20,000 to under $100,000: a second-degree felony, up to fifteen years.
  • $100,000 or more: a first-degree felony, up to thirty years.

We do not have data on how often prosecutors in Florida charge these cases. Do not read the list as a forecast.

There is also a civil side. Florida's civil theft law lets a person who proves theft by clear and convincing evidence seek three times their actual damages, with a $200 minimum, plus reasonable attorney's fees and court costs. Section 772.11(1). First, the person must send a written demand. If you comply with that demand within 30 days of getting it, the law says you are to be given a written release from further civil liability for that act. That release covers civil liability only. The remedy is never automatic. It requires proof of theft.

Intent is usually the fight. A Florida appeals court let a civil theft verdict stand against a man who kept money after admitting it belonged to someone else. But in a case over a mistaken duplicate wire of about $119,000, another panel held the recipients liable for conversion and still reversed the civil theft judgment, because clear and convincing proof of intent was missing.

What does the State say?

Here is the argument a prosecutor would make.

You did not take the money. But the law cares what you did with it. Spending is "use." The statute covers any unauthorized use.

Arriving innocent does not matter, the argument goes. What matters is the moment you learned it was not yours. After that, every dollar you spend is a choice.

A prosecutor would also say proof is easier than people think:

  • Texts or messages saying "wrong person"
  • A bank notice
  • Spending the money fast after you knew
  • Bank records showing where it went

Planning to pay it back later is not the safe harbor people think it is. The statute covers intent to deprive the owner "temporarily" as well as permanently.

What does the defense say?

Here is the argument a defense lawyer would make.

Theft is a crime of the mind. The State must prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that you acted knowingly and with intent to deprive. The money just showed up. You did nothing to get it.

The defense points out several facts that can matter:

  • Many people do not read every payment alert.
  • You may have had a real reason to expect money. A friend who owed you. A relative who was generous.
  • The question is what you knew at the time you used the money, not what became clear later.

Florida's standard jury instruction on theft recognizes a good faith defense. An honest, good faith belief that you had the right to possess the money is a defense, even if that belief was unreasonable or mistaken. A reasonable doubt on that point means not guilty.

The defense also has a line from the Florida Supreme Court to work with. In that old bank case, the court said it was not prepared to say that a person who innocently got too much money, and found the error later, would be guilty. That case came under the old larceny law, before today's theft statute. The current statute covers using property, so the State can answer that the old line no longer helps.

There is also a defense argument that a bank balance is not "property of another" in the first place. The defense can say the sender only has a claim to be repaid, which looks like a debt. The State can answer that the statute covers "rights, privileges, interests, and claims." Section 812.012(4)(b). That argument faces real trouble. Florida courts have treated a specific sum paid by mistake as property that can be converted, and the conviction described above involved a bank's mistaken credit. We found no Florida appellate opinion that decides the point for a mistaken Zelle.

So which side is right?

Both have a point. The honest bottom line:

A mistaken Zelle can be theft. Whether it is depends on what you knew, what you intended, and what can be proven.

That is not "always a crime." It is not "always safe" either.

Not noticing the money can be a defense. Noticing it and spending it anyway is a real risk, and a Florida court has upheld a conviction on facts like those. The sender's civil claim to get it back is much clearer than the criminal question.

What if I sent it by mistake?

Move fast.

  1. Open the app and check the payment. If the other person has not enrolled in Zelle yet, you may be able to cancel it there. If they are already enrolled, the money goes straight to their bank account and generally cannot be canceled.
  2. Call your own bank right away. Use the number on your card, not a number from a text or email. Ask what options exist, and follow up in writing.
  3. Screenshot everything: the payment, the name or number you typed, and any messages.
  4. If you know the person, ask them politely to return it. Keep it calm and keep it in writing.
  5. Do not threaten them with police. Threatening to accuse someone of a crime to get money can create legal trouble for you. If the money is not returned, talk to a lawyer about the proper civil steps.

One note on federal rules. Federal rules protect people against unauthorized transfers. A payment you sent yourself, with the wrong number, generally does not count as one. Still tell your bank at once. Do not assume a refund is owed.

What does Zelle say?

Zelle's own site says payments cannot be reversed. It says a payment can be canceled only if the recipient has not enrolled yet. Zelle's site has no page we could find on what to do when you receive money by mistake. (Source: zelle.com/faq, read November 2, 2026.)

Zelle moves money between banks. Each bank sets its own rules for its own customers.

What do the banks say, and how do they differ?

Most of the banks we checked say the same basic thing. Call us right away if you sent money to the wrong person, and we will see what options exist. Almost none tell the person who received the money what to do.

Here is where they differ. These are summaries, and policies change. Check your own bank's current terms.

  • Citi. Its deposit agreement says you are responsible for the correct phone number or email. It states: "You will be responsible for any keystroke or other errors you make when sending or requesting money."
  • BankUnited. Its terms say that, to the extent the law requires, it will "make a reasonable effort to stop or recover a payment made to the wrong person or entity once informed, but we do not guarantee such stoppage or recovery." Its FAQ also describes a fee to cancel a pending payment.
  • Space Coast Credit Union. Its terms use almost the same words: a "reasonable effort to stop or recover a payment made to the wrong person or entity once informed," with no guarantee. Stop-payment requests may need to be in writing within 14 days and may carry a fee.
  • Navy Federal. It says you do not have protections if you send money to the wrong person. It suggests contacting the recipient and asking for the money back. (Source: navyfederal.org, paraphrased.)
  • Many others, such as Chase, Regions, and City National Bank of Florida. They tell you to call right away to see what options are available. Chase's wording is from its business support page. Truist says to call right away to file a claim.

On the receiving side, Bank of America says it may hold an incoming Zelle payment for review. PNC's small-business Zelle terms go further. They let PNC hold a recipient's account, and even debit it, if PNC is told the funds are disputed or may be tied to fraud.

One more point. No bank page we read tells a person who got a mistaken payment to keep it.

Wait. Should I just send it back to whoever texts me?

No. This is where people get hurt.

There is a scam built around this exact moment. A stranger sends money that may come from a stolen card or hacked account. Then they text you: "Sorry, I sent that by mistake. Please send it back."

If you send it back, the first payment may later be undone as fraud, and you can be left responsible for what you sent. Your "refund" is real money, and it is gone. Regions Bank lists requests to send money back because of an "accidental payment" as a warning sign. An Oregon state regulator describes the same trick.

So do this:

  • Do not send money back because a stranger asked.
  • Never use a link or number from the message.
  • Call your own bank, using the number on your card. Ask how to return it the right way.
  • Keep screenshots of everything.

Senders should watch out too. Be wary of anyone who contacts you offering "recovery" help. Do not pay anyone who promises to get your money back.

What is still unclear?

A lot.

  • We searched Florida appellate case law and found no opinion on a mistaken Zelle payment. The closest cases involve bank errors, overpayments, and mistaken wires. A court could treat Zelle differently.
  • We found no Florida statute that deals directly with mistaken payments. We did not search every chapter.
  • We found no Florida criminal opinion that squarely decides the case of someone who received a payment innocently and decided later to keep it. Civil cases have allowed a finding that the intent formed later. An old criminal case left the question open.
  • We found no decision from Florida's appellate courts, or from the federal appeals court that covers Florida, on whether federal bank rules treat a wrong-recipient payment as an "error" the bank must investigate.
  • We do not know how often prosecutors file these cases.

That is why we do not tell you it is always a crime. We do not tell you it is always fine, either.

Frequently asked questions

I got a Zelle by mistake. Can I keep it?

Generally not, unless you have a real legal claim to it. You should expect the sender can ask for it back. Spending it after you know it is not yours can create criminal risk, depending on what you knew and intended.

Is keeping money sent by accident a crime in Florida?

It can be theft under Florida law. It depends on what you knew, what you intended, and what can be proven. An honest, good faith belief that you had the right to possess the money is a defense to theft. It does not stop a civil claim to get the money back.

What if I already spent it?

Keep every record, and do not contact the sender before you talk to a lawyer. Having spent it does not by itself excuse paying it back. Returning it the safe way, with a lawyer's advice, may help, but it does not automatically end the problem.

Can I be sued even if I did nothing wrong when it arrived?

Yes. A sender can generally seek the money back even without proof of a crime. That is a different question from a criminal charge.

I sent a Zelle to the wrong person. How do I get it back?

Call your bank right away, using the number on your card. Check whether the payment can still be canceled. Screenshot everything. Do not threaten the other person with police.

Is there a time limit?

Yes. Civil claims to recover a mistaken payment generally have a four-year limit in Florida. Civil theft has a five-year limit. Time rules have details, so do not wait to ask.

Does Zelle give the money back?

Zelle's site says payments cannot be reversed. Some banks' terms describe a reasonable effort to help, with no guarantee.

If you are in this spot

You should not have to sort it out alone.

Dennis Gonzalez Law, P.A. is a Miami firm that helps people with criminal charges and money questions like this one. Call (305) 209-0384, answered 24/7. The first consultation is free.

Learn more about theft cases in Florida and our mistaken Zelle checklist.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts, and laws and bank policies change.