In this article

You generally do not have to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurance company, and you should know what is at stake before you agree to one. You have no insurance contract with that company. The adjuster's job is to evaluate the claim for the company that may have to pay it. A recorded statement is a permanent record of your words, often taken before you know the full extent of your injuries. Your own insurer is different, and we explain how below.

Why the call comes so fast

Within days of a crash, you may get a friendly call from an insurance adjuster. They may tell you it is routine, that it will only take a few minutes, and that it will help get your claim moving. The call may come while you are still sore, still on pain medication or still waiting on a tow.

None of that is unusual, and not every adjuster is unfriendly. But the adjuster works for the insurance company, not for you. If you read our post on what to do when strangers show up at a crash scene, this is the same idea one step later: slow down, and decide who you talk to and when.

What a recorded statement is

It is a recorded interview, usually by phone, in which the adjuster asks about the crash, your injuries, your medical history and your daily life. The recording is kept. It can be transcribed and compared with your later medical records, your claim forms and anything you say in the future.

Why that matters:

  • Injuries change. Soreness on day two can look different on day twenty. Neck, back and head injuries are not always obvious on the first call. A casual "I'm okay" can be quoted back later.
  • Memory is imperfect. If you are unsure of a speed, a distance or a time, a guess on tape can be treated as a fact.
  • Questions can be broad. Questions about prior injuries, other doctors or past claims can reach far beyond this crash.
  • There is no editing. You cannot take a sentence back after the call.

Questions about your situation? Talk to Dennis.

Your insurer versus the other driver's insurer

This is where people get confused, and the answer depends on the specific policy.

  • Your own insurer. Your policy is a contract, and it may require you to cooperate with your insurer's investigation. Refusing to cooperate at all can create problems with your own coverage. If you are claiming PIP (personal injury protection) benefits, Florida law says you must comply with the terms of your policy, including sitting for an examination under oath if the insurer asks, and that compliance is a condition of getting PIP benefits. Cooperating does not mean answering without preparation.
  • The other driver's insurer. You have no policy with it, and it owes you no duty to protect your claim. It is evaluating what it may have to pay. You generally can say that you are not giving a recorded statement and that all communication should be in writing or through your lawyer.

Not sure which insurer is calling? Ask for the company name, the claim number, the adjuster's full name and a call-back number. Then pause the conversation.

What you can safely provide

Education only, not advice for your case.

  • Basic identifying facts: your name, your insurance information, the date and place of the crash.
  • Facts you can document: the make and model of the vehicles and where they were taken.

What to be careful about

  • Do not guess. If you do not know, say so.
  • Do not describe your injuries as minor, nothing, or fine. If you are hurt, or you do not yet know, say that you are still being evaluated.
  • Do not sign a broad medical authorization without reading it. A broad authorization can open up your whole medical history.
  • Do not discuss fault or guess about who caused the crash on tape. A statement about fault can be used later.
  • Do not sign or accept a quick payment without understanding what it releases.

Practical steps this week

  1. Photograph the vehicles, the scene and your injuries while they are fresh.
  2. See a doctor. Your health comes first, and your records show what happened. If you will use your PIP coverage, Florida law ties PIP medical benefits to getting initial care within 14 days after the crash.
  3. Keep a simple log of symptoms, missed work and out-of-pocket costs.
  4. Keep the adjuster's name, company and claim number. Save voicemails and emails.
  5. Mind the clock. Florida has filing deadlines for injury claims. Read our post on the deadline for injury claims in Florida and have a lawyer confirm the date for your case.

What a lawyer can do

A lawyer can take the calls, send the insurer what it is entitled to, and help make sure what is said on the record is accurate and complete once your injuries are better understood. You do not have to hire a lawyer on the first day. A free consultation before you say yes to a recorded statement costs you nothing.

See our overview of car crash injury claims for how these cases are built.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurance? Generally, no. You can ask that communication be in writing or go through your lawyer. Your own insurer may expect cooperation under your policy, so check before you refuse everything.

What if I already gave one? Don't panic. Write down what you remember being asked, ask the adjuster for a copy if one is available, and tell your lawyer. What matters now is what you do next.

Will refusing hurt my claim? Declining a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer does not by itself end your claim. Your claim still depends on the facts, your medical records and the evidence. No lawyer can promise how a claim will turn out.

Talk to a lawyer before you talk to the adjuster

If you were hurt in a crash in Miami-Dade or anywhere in Florida, call for a free consultation. We are available 24/7, in English or Spanish, at (305) 209-0384. No fee unless we win.

General information, not legal advice. Every case is different. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.