Punitive Damages in Florida: When the Law Says "Punish"

Most injury awards are meant to repair a loss. Punitive damages are different. They are not about repairing. They are about punishing conduct that goes far past carelessness, and warning others.

They are rare, they are hard to get, and Florida puts them behind a gate. The jury instructions, numbered 503.1 and 503.2, show why.

What the jury is told it must decide

In the usual two-part trial, instruction 503.1(a) opens like this:

"There is an additional claim in this case that you must decide. If you find for (claimant) and against (defendant(s)), you must decide whether, in addition to compensatory damages, punitive damages are warranted as punishment to [one or more of] (defendant(s)) and as a deterrent to others." Fla. Std. Jury Instr. (Civ.) 503.1(a).

Then comes the test. Instruction 503.1(b)(1):

"Punitive damages are warranted against (defendant) if you find by clear and convincing evidence that (defendant) was guilty of [intentional misconduct] [or] [gross negligence], which was a substantial cause of [loss] [injury] [or] [damage] to (claimant). Under those circumstances you may, in your discretion, award punitive damages against (defendant)." Fla. Std. Jury Instr. (Civ.) 503.1(b)(1).

Note the word "may." Even then, the jury is never required to award them.

The two kinds of bad conduct

The instruction defines both:

"'Intentional misconduct' means that (defendant) had actual knowledge of the wrongfulness of the conduct and there was a high probability of injury or damage to (claimant) and, despite that knowledge, [he] [she] intentionally pursued that course of conduct, resulting in injury or damage."

"'Gross negligence' means that (defendant's) conduct was so reckless or wanting in care that it constituted a conscious disregard or indifference to the life, safety, or rights of persons exposed to such conduct." Fla. Std. Jury Instr. (Civ.) 503.1(b)(1).

In plain English: this is not an ordinary mistake. It is knowing wrongdoing, or a conscious "I don't care who gets hurt." Cases that raise these claims sometimes involve a drunk driver with prior warnings, or a company accused of hiding a known danger.

A higher standard of proof

Ordinary claims use "greater weight of the evidence." Punitive damages need more. The instruction says:

"'Clear and convincing evidence' is evidence that is precise, explicit, lacking in confusion, and of such weight that it produces a firm belief or conviction, without hesitation, about the matter in issue." Fla. Std. Jury Instr. (Civ.) 503.1(b)(1).

Companies and employers

A business is not automatically liable for punitive damages because of what an employee did. Instruction 503.1(b)(3) says the jury may also punish the employer if, by clear and convincing evidence, the employer "actively and knowingly participated" in the conduct, its officers, directors, or managers "knowingly condoned, ratified, or consented to" it, or the employer's own gross negligence contributed to the harm. Other instructions cover managing agents and primary owners (503.1(b)(2)).

How and when it is pleaded

You cannot simply add a punitive claim to a first complaint in Florida. The law requires a "reasonable showing" first. Your lawyer files a motion asking the court for permission to add the claim, with evidence or a proffer of evidence behind it. The court decides whether there is a reasonable basis. Only then can the punitive claim be pleaded. Discovery about the defendant's finances waits until that gate is passed.

What you need to prove

• The underlying claim: negligence, legal cause, damages.
• Intentional misconduct or gross negligence, by clear and convincing evidence.
• For a company, the extra link described above.

Common defense arguments

• "A mistake is not gross negligence."
• "No proof the person knew of the danger."
• "The company did not condone it. Policies prohibited it."
• "Not clear and convincing."
• The statutory limits on how much can be awarded.
• Motions to keep the claim out before trial.

What to do now

1. Preserve everything: vehicles, phones, texts, photos, video, and reports.
2. Send a written preservation request to the other side as early as possible.
3. Identify prior complaints, violations, or arrests that show what they knew.
4. Get the police report and any citations or criminal case numbers.
5. Do not discuss the case with the other side's insurer.
6. Ask a lawyer early whether the facts support this claim.

Talk to us

Free consultation. Call (305) 209-0384. Answered 24/7. Se habla español.

This page is general information, not legal advice.